My Wife Threw Out My Card Collection (So I Bought a Dump to Find Them All) is a cozy, offbeat “trash-cleaning simulator” developed by the indie gamedev Pmdk23 and published by Polden Publishing. The game is set to release on November 25, 2025. In this indie game, you explore a massive junkyard, dig through piles of garbage, and search for ultra-rare collectible cards that were once thrown out — all while rescuing birds tangled in the trash.
Let’s follow us at Indie Games Tavern to dive in this indie game review, figure out what works well and what needs to be improved.
Gameplay & Core Loop
- Dig & Sort: The central mechanic is digging through heaps of trash. You sift through junk to find hidden cards, salvageable items, and even little “treasures”.
- Card Collecting: The main goal is to rebuild your lost card collection. Each pile offers a chance at finding ultra-rare cards, giving a satisfying collector’s loop.
- Bird Rescue: As you dig, you can rescue tangled birds from the trash and build them cozy nests, which adds a gentle side-task/purpose beyond card collecting.
- Humor & Nostalgia: The game leans into its absurd premise — a man buying a dump to retrieve his cards — with humor, irony, and a trippy “trash as art” aesthetic.
- No Combat: This is not a fight-based game. There are no battles — gameplay is peaceful, meditative, and focused on exploration and collection.
- Progression: According to the demo, you unlock more types of cards, items, and even ways to improve your trash-digging setup over time.
- Supporter Pack / Extras: There is a “Supporter Pack” DLC that includes cosmetic and fun items (e.g., a new look for your dog companion, a jukebox, crates) for players who want to support the game’s development.
- Charitable Impact: Not just fluff — the developers will donate a portion of proceeds to BirdLife International for real-world bird rescue.
To be honest, our team at Indie Games Tavern had some different thoughts to decide if we should play and review this indie game, luckily we did play. We had a great time, thanks for this hilarious idea from the indie game dev Pmdk23.
What Works Really Well
Uniquely Relaxing Gameplay
The concept of digging through trash to find lost cards is weirdly soothing. It’s meditative: no combat, just constant exploration, sorting, and hope of discovery.
Nostalgic Collector Appeal
For anyone who’s lost a cherished collection (or fears they might), the card-hunting loop strikes a nostalgic chord. The premise of “restoring what was discarded” is emotionally satisfying.
Charismatic Style & Humor
The game leans into its absurdity: the title alone is hilarious, and the “trash as art” stylization makes digging feel whimsical rather than gross. The bird rescue adds a sweet layer of purpose.
Positive Social Impact
Donating part of each sale to bird conservation (BirdLife International) gives the game more meaning beyond entertainment.
Areas for Improvement & Considerations
Performance & Lag Issues
Several demo players report serious performance problems. One user said:
“Super bad lag … takes a while for mouse settings to input … the cart is too glitchy … moving it around is too dangerous …”
If performance isn’t improved, it could dampen the relaxing fantasy.
Repetitive Visuals / Item Variety
According to discussion threads, some players feel the junk piles lack variety: “it’s really tiring seeing blow-up dolls every second”. More diverse trash items could help sustain interest.
Utility of Mechanic Elements
Some players question the purpose of certain mechanics. For example, the in-game dog companion is seen by some as not very helpful:
“The dog does seem pretty pointless … he seems to just find stuff that we are already finding”.
Likewise, rescuing birds is charming, but how deeply it integrates into the loop remains unclear.
UI / Navigation
Because it’s a simulator focused on sorting, digging, and inventory, a smooth UI is vital. Some users reported confusing menu layouts or awkward movement when managing trash and carts.
Bounce Between Demo and Full Experience
As only the demo is available to many currently, it’s hard to know how large, deep, or varied the final version will feel. The demo gives a taste but maybe not the full “dump-madness” the full game promises.
Final Thoughts
My Wife Threw Out My Card Collection (So I Bought a Dump to Find Them All) is a refreshingly oddball simulator that leans into the charm of obsession, nostalgia, and trash. It’s not about fighting monsters or building empires — it’s about digging, sorting, and hoping to recover something precious. For players who love relaxing, collection-driven gameplay, and don’t mind a bit of weirdness, this could be a delightful hobby game.
To us at Indie Games Tavern, to fully succeed, the game needs to iron out performance issues, diversify its junk mechanics, and make sure its rescue / collection systems feel rewarding rather than gimmicky. If the indie gamedev Pmdk23 nails the execution, this could be a sleeper hit in the “cozy but absurd” genre.
Who Should Play It?
- Collectors & Nostalgic Players: Anyone who has ever lost or cherished a card collection will appreciate the sentimental hunt.
- Sim / Casual Gamers: If you like simulation-style games (digging, managing, sorting) rather than action, this is a great pick.
- Relaxation Seekers: Players who want a calm, low-stress experience — no combat, no pressure, just discovery.
- Animal / Nature Lovers: The bird rescue mechanic adds a heartwarming dimension for players who care about wildlife.
- Indie Game Fans: Those who support quirky, personal projects and enjoy strong community interaction.
Who Might Wait or Skip It?
- Performance-Sensitive Gamers: If lag or unstable performance bothers you, you might wait for optimizations.
- Action Gamers: If you want battles, challenges, or high stakes, this slow-digging sim may feel too laid-back.
- Players Who Prefer Deep Systems: If you like complex progression or deep mechanics, you might find this too simplistic.
- Collectors Looking for Competition: There’s no PvP or “card battling” — if you want a competitive card game, this may not satisfy.
- Budget / Value-Oriented Buyers: As a niche indie game, some may prefer to wait for reviews or a discount before diving in.
My Wife Threw Out My Card Collection Review by Indie Games Tavern.
Your cozy corner of indie gems. We’re more than just a indie game review channel, we’re a sanctuary for the unsung heroes of indie gamedev. Born from a love of the underdog, the quirky, and the downright brilliant, the Indie Games Tavern is your trusty guildhall for discovering the finest indie games—those hidden gems, wild experiments, and heartfelt labors that big studios often overlook. Picture this: a weathered oak table laden with scrolls—each a indie game review penned by your tavern scribes, folks like me who’ve braved the pixelated wilds to bring you tales of triumph, terror, and everything in between.
Indie Games Tavern 
Leave a comment